Our Waffle Maker performance TestBirch Benders Mix

Matthew Lee
Lap Vo
Test Lead
Tuyet Pham
Professional Chef
Nguyen Ntk
Visual Specialist

Many people don’t have the time or energy to mix their waffle batter from scratch. It is the reason why pre-mixed waffle batter is so popular. Just pour the raw flour from the box, add water, and a few minor ingredients like cooking oil, et voilà!

If you’re a fan of pre-mixed batter, the results in this test could be the critical deciding factor on whether that specific waffle maker is a good fit for you or not.

Why the Test Matters

Its popularity is just part of why we decided to include boxed batters in our test.

Though they may look the same, a pre-mixed batter has vastly different characteristics than a self-mixed one. A waffle made from a pre-mixed batter will look and, more importantly, taste different from one made using a full recipe. For this reason, we have decided that there has to be a separate test for the pre-mixed batter.

Additionally, by comparing the performance score in this section with the scores of other recipes (self-mixed and cornmeal waffle recipes), we can better understand how versatile the particular waffle maker is. The higher and more uniform the scores in all three recipes are, the more capable it is at dealing with different recipes and batter styles.

Testing Recipe

We use the Birch Benders Organic Classic pancake and waffle mix for all of our waffle makers. Using the ratio at the back of the box, we mix our batter in the following proportions, which is enough for 5-6 servings of 7-inch waffles:

  • 2 cups of waffle mix
  • 1 ¾ cups of water
  • 3 ½ tablespoons of oil

Step 1: Pre-heat the waffle maker to 180°C — 200°C.

Step 2: Combine the waffle mixture with water and oil.

Step 3: Mix until all of the ingredients combine.

Step 4: Pour the batter into the waffle maker.

Testing Procedure

How Did We Find the Most Optimal Temperature and Time Settings for Our Waffle Makers?

The quality and characteristics of the batter alone don’t necessarily make a good waffle. For a high-quality waffle to be born, it has to be cooked at the correct temperature for the right amount of time. The objective of this calibration test is to find the exact temperature and timing marks for the waffle maker.

We conduct a calibration test with each new waffle maker that passes through our lab and every new recipe.

Because this is the second performance test in the pipeline (behind the self-made recipe test), at this point, we’ve already got an idea of what the optimal temperature and timing settings are. So, we recycle these numbers and see if the qualities of the produced waffles are consistent. We then make adjustments based on what we see (decreasing temperature, increasing cooking time, etc.)

Adjustments are continuously made until we find the best configuration for the waffle maker and the recipe.

Performance Test

The performance test is conducted as usual. After mixing up the batter, we pour it onto the waffle plate. When we close the lid, a timer is started. Using the calibration test, this timer is set to the optimal timing we obtained earlier.

When the timer beeps, the lid is lifted, and the waffle is transferred onto a plate. It is delivered immediately to our in-house chef for assessment and scoring.

Scoring Scale

The waffle is scored using three metrics: coloring (35%), texture (25%), and taste (40%).

We also base our performance test around cooking time. A good waffle with superb coloration, texture, and taste usually takes less than 10 minutes to finish cooking. Hence, if a waffle maker takes over 10 minutes to cook but also doesn’t manage to produce an edible waffle, then we will strike it as a failure. Scoring for all three metrics is going to be zero.


The ideal waffle should have a beautiful golden brown color. It shouldn’t look too dark, which indicates charring. It also shouldn’t look too light, which could signify that it’s undercooked.

Besides having the right tone, it should also be uniform. There shouldn’t be any abnormally light or dark spots peppered throughout the waffle.

  • Golden brown, uniform color distribution: >=9.5
  • Light or dark gold, minimal discolored spots: 8 - 9.4
  • Light or dark brown, multiple discolored spots: 7 - 7.9
  • Very light gold or very dark brown, multiple discolored spots: 5 - 6.9
  • Pale gold (undercooked) or black (charred): <=5
Cuisinart WAF-F20P1 5 minutes
Cuisinart WAF-F20P1 — Top color result: Golden brown — Score: 10
Bella waffle maker 8 minutes
Bella waffle maker — Top color result: Light gold — Score: 8
Chefman waffle maker Bottom
Chefman waffle maker — Top color result: Light brown — Score: 7.5
Birch Benders Mix Very light gold
Hamilton Beach 26031 — Top color result: Very light gold — Score: 6.5
BLACK DECKER WMD200 7 minutes 30 seconds
BLACK+DECKER waffle maker — Top color result: Pale gold — Score: 5

In cases where coloring differs between the two sides of the waffle, the total score is calculated by averaging the individual score of each side. The score is then subtracted per the five-point scale above. With each degree of difference, 0.25 is taken off from the total score.

For example:

In our performance test, the BLACK+DECKER WMD200B made a waffle with distinctly contrasting coloration. By averaging the scores of the two sides, we received a rough total score of 7 ([9+5]/2). Because the score bands of the top and bottom differ by three levels on our scale, a further 0.75 is subtracted.

We finally received a final total score afterward being 6.25.

Birch Benders Mix Dark gold
Score: 9 — Top color result: Dark gold
Birch Benders Mix Dark Pale gold
Score: 5 — Bottom color result: Pale gold


A good waffle should be fluffy and pliant enough to melt on the tongue.

Birch Benders Mix Texture

However, it shouldn't be so soft that it breaks apart when picked up. It also shouldn't be so burnt that the crust immediately crumbles when it's touched. In both of these cases, that's an automatic fail.

Besides the texture, we also pay close attention to the number of air bubbles residing within the core of the waffle. The more bubbles there are, the softer the waffle will be. These bubbles form due to a process called aeration, which is a crucial stage in the development of the waffle as it consolidates from a liquid batter to a solid shape.

  • Perfect (Multiple bubbles observed, perfect springiness, and interior is fully cooked): >=9.5
  • Excellent (Displaying a decent number of air bubbles, decently springy, interior is fully cooked): 8 - 9.4
  • Good (Good number of bubbles, springy but may not fully come back to original shape, interior is fully cooked): 7 - 7.9
  • Mediocre (Small number of bubbles, springiness is minimal): 5 - 6.9
  • Bad (Little to no bubbles observed, does not return to original shape at all after compression, inside is undercooked and runny): <=5
The golden core of the waffle produced by the Cuisinart WAF-F20P1 Double waffle maker.
Cuisinart WAF-F20P1 — 5 minutes — Score: 9.5
The interior of a waffle baked for 3 minutes using a Birch Benders batter mix. Small air cavities can be seen within.
Oster waffle maker — 3 minutes — Score: 6
A cross-section of a waffle baked for 10 minutes using the Birch Benders batter mix, showcasing its dense, irregular interior
Krups Waffle Maker — 10 minutes — Score: 0


Taste is the most critical benchmark in our test. A waffle could look splendid and have the softest texture but will still be considered a failure if it doesn't taste good.

Unfortunately, grading a waffle's taste is tricky as everyone has a different palette. Some prefer sweet and light waffles. Others prefer saltier or more bitter and crispier waffles. So, the scoring in this section is subjective, depending on the palette of our in-house chef. Despite this, the taste score can still be a good reference point for judging the quality of the waffle maker.

After our test waffle batches have finished cooking, they are delivered to our kitchen, where they will be judged by our in-house chef: Tuyet Pham.

Related Tests